I believe in Global Warming in that the Seasonally Frozen Wastelands no longer get cold enough to get rid of riff-raff. Whether PEOPLE have caused that, is still debatable.
[Ooops. Lost a quote here, and I'm too lazy to find it again. It was your "B" point--"because you have yet explained why cat converters should be required other than it makes a funny smell. "]
1. Because they're effective in reducing tailpipe emissions
2. Because they eliminate the stench of hydrocarbon emissions
3. Because the high-flow, monolithic cats aren't restrictive like the original GM pellet-style. The only benefit of pellets over honeycomb is that the pellets could be removed and replaced--making that style of catalytic converter "rebuildable"
4. Because it's Federal law.
I don't know about the manufacturing of cat converters. If you say they're not made in the US, then I agree that's a shame. Whole swaths of American industry have been wiped-out by the Communists, and the Communist Collaborators in Industry and--especially--Government.
I'm more concerned about the hollowing-out of the Medications industry and the Electronics industry than the exhaust industry--but all are a problem.