That +12 bass setting might be causing some poor frequency response. That's usually there to boost the bottom end of a sub's passband that is usually otherwise missing, such as in a sealed box. You really don't need it if you're going for sound quality as the box is designed to give you a linear frequency response. Just crank the gains up a bit instead.
Since we know you're using quality amps, you can safely assume that you will be louder than most people who spend 2-3x as much as you did. Here's why. We perceive loudness in decibels. a 10db increase is perceived as a doubling in loudness to our ears. It takes you 2x the amount of power to increase output by 3db, so if you are playing at 100db at 200W, and you give your sub 400W, you will only increase loudness by 30%. While its a decent chunk, you can see why there are diminishing gains the more power you provide. You can provide half the power as someone who has a very expensive 12" sub in a sealed box and be louder. The box I designed for you gives you as linear of a frequency response as possible, while boosting output by a good 8db on the low end (which is why you don't really need that +12db bass boost).
I'm glad this thing pounds as hard as it does. I'd love to be able to hear it in person.
If this kind of thing interests you, I can teach you about subwoofer and speaker design.